ONE LEVEL DEEPER
ASML
ASML Holding N.V.
CONVERGENCE
WHERE 5 FRAMEWORKS LAND

ASML just achieved something it has never done in its entire history: earned more than its cost of capital. ROIC hit 10.71% versus a 10.41% WACC in Q4'25, marking a fundamental inflection point. Yet the stock trades 267.7% above its DCF value with an earnings yield of 0.81% against 4.33% treasuries — a valuation that assumes this breakthrough is just the beginning.

WHERE THEY AGREE

ASML's moat is as wide as technology gets — but the price has already traveled across it

All three cite the EUV monopoly and 35.3% operating margins as evidence of an exceptional business, yet find the 0.81% earnings yield versus 4.33% treasuries makes it uninvestable at current prices.

Buffett · Graham · Lynch

The fundamental inflection is real — ROIC crossing above WACC for the first time in company history

ROIC reached 10.71% in Q4'25 versus 10.41% cost of capital, with revenue accelerating to 29.3% quarterly growth from 15.6% trailing.

Mauboussin · Lynch · Buffett

Geographic concentration creates a risk that transcends any framework

81% of revenue comes from just three countries: China (29.6%), Taiwan (25.9%), and South Korea (25.4%) — a concentration that could override any moat.

Marks · Graham · Mauboussin
WHERE THEY DISAGREE

Is peak performance the moment to buy or the moment to sell?

MAUBOUSSIN · LYNCH

The inflection point signals multi-year value creation ahead

ROIC finally exceeding WACC at 10.71% vs 10.41%, with the market pricing only 8.13% growth versus 29.3% actual in Q4'25.

VS
MARKS · GRAHAM

Peak margins and peak multiples create maximum downside risk

Operating margins at 35.3% near historical peaks, while 558 institutions pile in at 31x earnings and 267.7% above DCF value.

Does the 95.4% correlation with inflation represent pricing power or cyclical vulnerability?

MAUBOUSSIN

Inflation correlation proves ASML can pass through any cost increase

Revenue correlates 95.4% with CPI and grows during economic stress, with positive 73.7% correlation to Fed Funds rates.

VS
MARKS · BUFFETT

The same correlation signals dangerous cyclical exposure at cycle peaks

Counter-cyclical patterns (-84.9% correlation with consumer sentiment) suggest vulnerability when cycles turn, especially at 0.81% earnings yield.

CONSENSUS RISKMEDIUM

The 40-point spread reflects a fundamental question about timing: everyone sees the same inflection point, but they disagree violently on whether the market has already priced it in. When legends can't agree despite seeing the same 10.71% ROIC breakthrough, retail investors face maximum uncertainty.

THE BLIND SPOT

All five frameworks miss the company's unusual resilience pattern: ASML actually thrives during rate hikes (73.7% correlation with Fed Funds) and credit stress (61.5% correlation with BAA spreads). This counter-intuitive dynamic suggests the business model benefits from the very conditions that typically punish growth stocks — a characteristic that could make traditional valuation frameworks misleading.

THE QUESTION

If ASML trades at 31x earnings with its first-ever positive ROIC-WACC spread of 30 basis points, what multiple would you pay when that spread reaches 500 basis points?

DIVE INTO ANY FRAMEWORK
Peter Lynch framework
The Everyday Edge
Bullish
Michael Mauboussin framework
The Expectations Engineer
Bullish
Warren Buffett framework
The Owner-Operator
Leaning Bullish
Benjamin Graham framework
The Value Architect
Neutral
Howard Marks framework
The Cycle Whisperer
Leaning Bearish
Explore
Workday, Inc.WDAYLinde plcLINAtlassian CorporationTEAMDiamondback Energy, Inc.FANGBaker Hughes CompanyBKRThomson Reuters CorporationTRI
EDUCATIONAL ONLY · NOT FINANCIAL ADVICE5 frameworks